Previously …

The era before “reading the code of life” — discriminating DNA and proteins mainly by their physical properties: size and charge.

  • Gel electrophoresis — simple, rapid, sensitive;
  • different ways to create patterns:
    • restrictases — site-specific cutting;
    • PCR — primer-specific amplification;
    • combinations of the two.
  • These methods are still relevant today.

Molekulaarsete andmete eelised

  • DNA ja valgu järjestused on rangelt pärilikud (arvestada tuleb horisontaalse geeniülekande võimalusega ja sugulise paljunemise puhul homoloogse rekombinatsiooniga);
  • tunnuste — nukleotiidi- või aminohappepositsioonide — ja tunnuse seisundite kirjeldus on üheselt mõistetav;
  • tunnused on sõltumatud: asendus ühes positsioonis ei mõjuta asendumist teistes;
  • andmed on kvantitatiivselt kergemini töödeldavad, saab kasutada matemaatilisi meetodeid;
  • võimaldavad võrrelda väga kaugeid organisme;
  • informatsiooni suur hulk: imetaja genoom ~3 miljardit nukleotiidipaari, bakteri genoom 0.5 – >10 miljonit.

Proportion of phylogeography articles per year, by marker class

Molecular genetic markers

  • Molecular markers can address ecological questions that are difficult to pursue in any other way.
  • A primary advantage: markers and their variation can be quantified with greater precision than most other ecological measurements — better data for statistical comparison.
  • They have become instrumental in understanding the patterns and processes behind extant global biodiversity.
  • Using a marker means taking a sample from the whole genome — and any sample carries sampling error.
  • A single marker type and a small number of loci increases that error and can lead to misinterpretation.

DNA and DNA — different sources

  • Eukaryotes: genomic DNA (gDNA), chloroplast DNA (cpDNA), mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA);
  • Prokaryotes: chromosomal DNA, plasmids, cloning vectors;
  • microbial community — the metagenome;
  • ncDNA — non-coding DNA;
  • eDNA — environmental DNA;
  • aDNA — ancient DNA;
  • cDNA — complementary DNA synthesised from an mRNA template.

Genomics

Whole genome sequences are rapidly becoming available for a wide range of organisms. Comparative genomics uses megabases of data — rather than short sequences from a few genes — to build phylogenies and investigate the mechanisms of speciation.

  • Pan genome — all genes and genetic variation within a species;
  • Core genome — the portion common to all individuals;
  • Dispensable genome — the portion present only in a subset, or unique to individuals.

Comparative genomics

A large-scale, holistic approach: compare two or more genomes to find similarities and differences, and study the biology of each — a highly detailed view of how organisms are related at the gene level.

Non-nuclear DNA

  • High copy number. A mitochondrion or chloroplast holds multiple copies of its DNA, and a cell holds many organelles — often thousands of copies per cell.
  • Random segregation. Organelles are randomly distributed to daughter cells during mitosis and meiosis.
  • Single-parent inheritance. Non-nuclear DNA is often inherited uniparentally — in humans, mitochondrial DNA comes from the mother.

Endosymbiosis

Similarities between the DNA of mitochondria and chloroplasts and the DNA of bacteria are an important line of evidence for the endosymbiont theory — that both originated as free-living prokaryotic cells.

Vertical vs horizontal gene transfer

Vertical gene transfer happens between generations.

Horizontal gene transfer moves genetic material from one organism to another that is not its offspring — most common among prokaryotes.

Hoiatus

Horizontal transfer is why a single-gene tree is a gene tree, not necessarily a species tree.

Mitochondrial DNA

Why mtDNA took over from allozymes

  • Nuclear DNA is problematic in RFLP analysis; the method found much wider ecological application with mtDNA.
  • Restriction mapping of mtDNA was an important improvement over allozyme electrophoresis.
  • No recombination during meiosis — so networks of relationships among mtDNA lineages within and among populations can be constructed.
  • mtDNA is usually inherited maternally, so only the behaviour and movements of females are effectively tracked.

mtDNA — size and organisation

  • Size and organisation vary — 11–28 kbp in animals.
  • Animal mtDNA: 13 protein-coding, 22 tRNA, and 2 rRNA genes.
  • The mutation rate is relatively high — 5.8 × 10⁻⁸ substitutions per site per year in mammals, about 10× higher than synonymous substitutions in nuclear protein-coding DNA.
  • A non-coding region contains the displacement (D) loop.

Universal primers

  • Kocher et al. (1989) were the first to develop what came to be called universal primers, for three regions of mtDNA — so a species can be studied without prior sequence knowledge.
  • Cytochrome b is part of the electron transport chain and the main subunit of the cytochrome bc₁ and b₆f complexes; it is commonly used for phylogenetic relationships.
  • Kocher’s cyt b primers are the underlying reason sequences of this gene exist for so many species today.
  • Mutation in one or both primer regions means “universal” primers do not work on all species — they are really just versatile primers.

Phylogeography

Because mtDNA does not recombine to any significant extent, lineage networks can be built and analysed in a geographic context.

Avise et al. (1987) coined the term phylogeography — encompassing both intraspecific phylogeny and geography.

Phylogeographic studies increased dramatically in the early 1990s and added substantially to our understanding of how current species distributions came into being.

Phylogeography of Genetta genetta from Bayesian analysis of cytochrome b + the left domain of the control region

Wolf vs coyote — three marker types

mtDNA Microsat. SNP
Loci one 10–20 millions
Copies/cell thousands few few
Inheritance maternal biparental biparental
Recombination no yes yes

Identification of species

How many species are there on Earth?

  • Catalogue of Life, 2019 Annual Checklist: information on 1,837,565 living and 63,418 extinct species.
  • Mora et al. (2011) predicted globally around 8.7 million eukaryotic species, of which about 2.2 million are marine.
  • Vertebrates — particularly birds and mammals — are comparatively very well documented.
  • Molecular markers keep revealing cryptic species not previously recognised because of similar morphology.

The species problem

  • What is a species? Surprisingly, a significant and much-debated question in biology — the species problem.
  • Biologists are now reconciled that no single definition applies to all species under all circumstances; at least twenty-two species concepts are in use.
  • Frankham et al. (2012) found that different concepts often yielded different numbers of species and disparate groupings — with financial, legal, biological, and conservation implications.
  • Urmas Kõljalg — the species hypothesis: more fluid and practical than species assignment.

Morphological species concept (MSC)

  • Historically, species were recognised by sharing a similar morphology, with individuals conforming to a ‘type’.
  • Also known as the typological species concept (TSC).
  • A ‘common sense’ approach, and a frequently used definition in any first assessment.
  • Problems: large phenotypic variation within or between populations; marked differences between the sexes, between juveniles and adults, or between developmental stages.
  • Cryptic species will be very under-recorded.

Biological species concept (BSC)

  • Places emphasis on reproductive isolation between populations, not on morphology (Mayr 1942, 1963).
  • A species is “groups of actually or potentially interbreeding natural populations in the wild”.
  • Species are recognised on the basis of a shared gene pool; individuals are consequently often — but not always — similar in morphology.
  • Rejected by most botanists, because of the large number of plants that reproduce asexually (Mayden 1997).
  • The same problem arises in microbiology.

Phylogenetic species concept (PSC)

  • Places emphasis on monophyletic genetic lineages.
  • Increasingly applicable alongside the rise in available molecular data.
  • A species is the smallest aggregation of populations (sexual) or lineages (asexual) diagnosable by a unique combination of apomorphous (derived) traits in comparable individuals descended from a shared common ancestor.
  • The difficulty is the definition of unique traits: phylogenetic lineages can be divided into ever smaller clades on the basis of trivial — but nonetheless shared and unique — traits.

Operational taxonomic unit (OTU)

  • An OTU is a group of organisms treated as a distinct evolutionary unit for the purposes of the research underway, which for various reasons has not — or cannot — be given a Linnaean binomial name.
  • Mainly applied to single-celled microorganisms, though the concept is sometimes used for larger organisms, e.g. recently discovered sibling species awaiting recognition — candidate species.
  • OTUs can be defined on morphology, molecules, or both — usually the latter. Very commonly by % similarity of the rRNA gene.
  • mOTU — molecular operational taxonomic unit — is also used, particularly for cryptic species.

The concepts side by side

Concept Criterion Strength Where it fails
Morphological (MSC) shared ‘type’ fast, no lab cryptic species, dimorphism, larvae
Biological (BSC) reproductive isolation mechanistic asexual taxa, plants, microbes, fossils
Phylogenetic (PSC) monophyly, apomorphies uses molecular data where to stop splitting
OTU / mOTU % sequence similarity operational, scalable threshold is a convention, not a boundary

DNA barcoding

  • DNA barcoding (liikide vöötkodeerimine) is the use of short gene sequences from a standardised portion of the genome to identify species.
  • The concept has been around for well over a decade, but high-throughput technology has moved it into a new phase of application.
  • In the ideal case, a barcode marker works for all species.
  • Markers applied to specific taxonomic groups are proving invaluable — and very cost-effective — for species boundaries, community ecology, functional trait evolution, trophic interactions, and conservation.
  • Barcoding identifies a species by matching the sequence to a reference library.

Universal primers, revisited

A usable barcode needs conserved flanking regions to anchor the primers, and a variable region in between that carries the species signal.

That trade-off — conserved enough to amplify, variable enough to discriminate — is the whole design problem.

The barcoding idea

  • The initial idea was simple: select one or a few genes shared by most — if not all — organisms, showing large interspecific (liikide vaheline) but small intraspecific (liigisisene) variation.
  • Such sequences are the equivalent of species-specific barcodes.
  • Future outlook: portable sequencers allow species identification in the field, even by people with little or no taxonomic training — e.g. with Nanopore.

DNA barcoding: COI

  • Early work focused on the mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase subunit 1 (cox1), referred to as COI in barcoding studies (Hebert et al. 2003).
  • Desirable properties: present in high copy number per cell; a partial sequence of about 650 bp shows high interspecific and low intraspecific variation across organisms from insects to birds.
  • Problems: many anaerobic organisms are excluded; interspecific variation of mtDNA in plants and fungi is often too low to be useful.
  • Mitogenomics — the use of complete mtDNA sequences for identification and evolutionary studies, thanks to NGS.

COI — proof of concept

Inter- and intraspecific COI distances among mayflies (Barr et al. 2005): means of 18.1% vs 1.1%

Mayflies (ühepäevikulised, Ephemeroptera) are widely used in the biomonitoring of aquatic habitats. Identifying adults by morphology requires substantial training, and larval identification can be highly problematic.

DNA barcoding: plants and fungi

Chloroplast (cpDNA) loci:

  • the intergenic spacer region trnH-psbA;
  • ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase — rbcL;
  • maturase K — matK.

Nuclear loci:

  • the ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer (ITS) — sisemine transkribeeritav speisser — also used for fungi.

An aside: nanopore and the IP war

Claims for breach of contractual obligations, of common law obligations of confidence, of duties under trade secrets regulations, plus an entitlement claim to a licence of certain patents — against BGI Tech Solutions, BGI Group, Beijing Genomics Institute at Shenzhen, and MGI.

Märkus

The tools you plan a decade of monitoring around are commercial products in a contested market.

DNA metabarcoding and eDNA

DNA metabarcoding

  • A molecular alternative to classical taxonomic approaches for high-throughput biodiversity assessment, becoming a standard in biodiversity research.
  • DNA metabarcoding — the use of NGS for automated identification of multiple species from a single bulk sample containing entire organisms, or from an environmental sample containing degraded DNA.
  • eDNA analysis — presence/absence or quantification of large, multicellular organisms (usually vertebrates) in an environmental sample (usually water) using species-specific PCR primers.
  • Metabarcoding also extends into ancient DNA.

Limits of metabarcoding

  • Limited by its dependency on PCR and by the considerable investment needed to build comprehensive reference libraries.
  • PCR problems: errors introduced during amplification from environmental samples (degraded template); primers need conserved regions, and PCR is biased.
  • The trade-off: genes easy to amplify in all species are highly conserved and underestimate the true number of species; genes that describe species number better are harder to amplify.

Environmental DNA and RNA

  • Total eDNA contains cellular DNA (living cells or organisms) and extracellular DNA (from natural cell death and destruction of cell structure). Organisms shed DNA through mucous, skin cells, faecal matter, and degrading carcasses.
  • It can be collected from essentially any environmental sample: soil, freshwater, seawater, snow, air.
  • It lets researchers monitor species presence at larger spatial scales, more efficiently — particularly useful for rare or hard-to-see aquatic organisms.
  • RNA is likewise found in environmental samples and is termed eRNA.

Barcoding, eDNA barcoding, eDNA metabarcoding

Same barcode logic, three different starting materials and three different readouts — Sanger, qPCR, and NGS.

qPCR, RT-qPCR and variations of dPCR

Case study — marine fishes from seawater

Number of fish species recorded by nine conventional survey methods and by eDNA at The Sound of Elsinore, Denmark — the eDNA bar comes from 0.5 litre of seawater.

Many factors affect dropping and picking up eDNA

Release, degradation, transportation, and sedimentation — each with its own abiotic and biotic drivers (Takahashi et al. 2023)

Running water is an issue

Environmental DNA detection rates by qPCR in natural freshwater ponds — % positive localities out of the total surveyed for each species.

In lakes and ponds the signal stays where the organism is. In streams it arrives from upstream, so a detection is a statement about a catchment, not a site.

Stringency and uncertainty

What criteria constitute a species detection?

The lack of consensus results from context dependency — total species diversity, sequencing depth, marker specificity — and from the trade-off between stringency and uncertainty when interpreting metabarcoding results.

Which markers? What frequency across samples?

Limits of detection and quantification

  • LOD — the lowest concentration of target that can be detected with a defined level of confidence; the standard is a 95% detection rate.
  • LOQ — reflects the assay’s capacity to precisely quantify copy number.

Klymus et al. 2019

Invasive species

A decision strategy for an eDNA monitoring approach to non-indigenous species (NIS): targeted or whole-community, semi-quantitative or qualitative, lab-based or on-site.

Ancient DNA

Ancient DNA

  • aDNA — DNA isolated from ancient specimens, sediments, and similar material.
  • It started with museum specimens of extinct species.
  • Pre-PCR: Higuchi et al. (1984) studied mtDNA of the extinct quagga, whose last captive individual had died the year before — the work that inspired Michael Crichton’s 1990 novel Jurassic Park.
  • Studies moved from single individuals and populations to understanding ancient ecosystems.
  • Complete genomes of extinct species: Miller et al. (2008) used 454 pyrosequencing to obtain 4.17 Gbp from two woolly mammoth specimens.

Equus quagga quagga — väljasurnud sebrataoline hobuslane

Sedimentary ancient DNA — sedaDNA

Sedimentary ancient DNA sequences reveal marine ecosystem shifts and indicator taxa for glacial–interglacial sea-ice conditions

Technically challenging

  • Everything degrades over time — fragmentation, chemical modification, and mutation accumulate.
  • Present-day contamination can lead to false conclusions: the contaminant amplifies better than the target, every time.

The damage signature is the authentication

Cytosine deamination at the fragment ends produces the C→T excess in the first few positions. Modern contaminant reads do not show it — which is why the damage pattern is used as evidence of authenticity, not just as a nuisance.

Ribosomal RNA barcoding

Carl R. Woese

The tree keeps growing

16S ribosomal RNA

The 16S rRNA gene is about 1600 bp long and includes nine hypervariable regions (V1–V9) of varying conservation.

V3 and V4 are the most commonly used — a suitable length for second-generation sequencing, combined with good variability.

18S ribosomal RNA

  • The V4 region has the highest length polymorphism and is the longest variable region in the rRNA gene — 350 to 450 nt.
  • The V9 region is characterised by high nucleotide variability in the centre, covering approximately 60 nt.

Standardised multi-omics of Earth’s microbiomes

Earth Microbiome Project Ontology (EMPO) categories: free-living vs host-associated, saline vs non-saline, and the substrate — a controlled vocabulary that makes thousands of independent studies comparable.

Ribosomal RNA databases

SILVA taxonomy, v138.2 released July 2024.

The Greengenes2 phylogeny — Bray–Curtis on collapsed genus data, weighted UniFrac at ASV and genome identifier levels.

EUKARYOME — a community-curated database for 18S (SSU), ITS, and 28S (LSU) markers for all eukaryotes.

Check yourself

Why is mtDNA so widely used in phylogeography?

High copy number (so it amplifies from poor material), no recombination (so lineages form a network), and maternal inheritance (so the genealogy is simple). The cost is that it tracks one locus and only the female line.

Why is COI a poor barcode for plants and fungi?

Their mitochondrial substitution rates are low, so interspecific COI variation is often too small to separate species. Plants use rbcL, matK, and trnH-psbA; fungi use ITS.

What is the “barcode gap”, and what happens when it closes?

The gap between intraspecific and interspecific genetic distances — 1.1% vs 18.1% in the mayfly example. Where recent divergence, hybridisation, or introgression closes it, sequences cannot be assigned to species with any threshold.

Why does a detection near the LOD need more replicates, not more confidence?

Below the LOD, detection is stochastic: the target may not enter the reaction at all. Replication converts a single uncertain result into a detection frequency, which is the quantity you can actually interpret.

How is ancient DNA authenticated?

By its damage: short fragments and an excess of C→T substitutions at the fragment ends from cytosine deamination. Contaminating modern DNA is long and undamaged.

Thank you

Tähtis

peeter.laas@ut.ee · peeter.laas@taltech.ee

Next lecture: sampling and nucleic acid extraction — how the material that all of this depends on is actually obtained.