MLB7052.LT: Modern Methods in Molecular Ecology
TalTech / UT Institute of Technology
The era before “reading the code of life” — discriminating DNA and proteins mainly by their physical properties: size and charge.
Proportion of phylogeography articles per year, by marker class
Whole genome sequences are rapidly becoming available for a wide range of organisms. Comparative genomics uses megabases of data — rather than short sequences from a few genes — to build phylogenies and investigate the mechanisms of speciation.
A large-scale, holistic approach: compare two or more genomes to find similarities and differences, and study the biology of each — a highly detailed view of how organisms are related at the gene level.
Similarities between the DNA of mitochondria and chloroplasts and the DNA of bacteria are an important line of evidence for the endosymbiont theory — that both originated as free-living prokaryotic cells.
Vertical gene transfer happens between generations.
Horizontal gene transfer moves genetic material from one organism to another that is not its offspring — most common among prokaryotes.
Hoiatus
Horizontal transfer is why a single-gene tree is a gene tree, not necessarily a species tree.
Because mtDNA does not recombine to any significant extent, lineage networks can be built and analysed in a geographic context.
Avise et al. (1987) coined the term phylogeography — encompassing both intraspecific phylogeny and geography.
Phylogeographic studies increased dramatically in the early 1990s and added substantially to our understanding of how current species distributions came into being.
Phylogeography of Genetta genetta from Bayesian analysis of cytochrome b + the left domain of the control region
| mtDNA | Microsat. | SNP | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loci | one | 10–20 | millions |
| Copies/cell | thousands | few | few |
| Inheritance | maternal | biparental | biparental |
| Recombination | no | yes | yes |
| Concept | Criterion | Strength | Where it fails |
|---|---|---|---|
| Morphological (MSC) | shared ‘type’ | fast, no lab | cryptic species, dimorphism, larvae |
| Biological (BSC) | reproductive isolation | mechanistic | asexual taxa, plants, microbes, fossils |
| Phylogenetic (PSC) | monophyly, apomorphies | uses molecular data | where to stop splitting |
| OTU / mOTU | % sequence similarity | operational, scalable | threshold is a convention, not a boundary |
A usable barcode needs conserved flanking regions to anchor the primers, and a variable region in between that carries the species signal.
That trade-off — conserved enough to amplify, variable enough to discriminate — is the whole design problem.
Inter- and intraspecific COI distances among mayflies (Barr et al. 2005): means of 18.1% vs 1.1%
Mayflies (ühepäevikulised, Ephemeroptera) are widely used in the biomonitoring of aquatic habitats. Identifying adults by morphology requires substantial training, and larval identification can be highly problematic.
Chloroplast (cpDNA) loci:
Nuclear loci:
Claims for breach of contractual obligations, of common law obligations of confidence, of duties under trade secrets regulations, plus an entitlement claim to a licence of certain patents — against BGI Tech Solutions, BGI Group, Beijing Genomics Institute at Shenzhen, and MGI.
Märkus
The tools you plan a decade of monitoring around are commercial products in a contested market.
Same barcode logic, three different starting materials and three different readouts — Sanger, qPCR, and NGS.
Number of fish species recorded by nine conventional survey methods and by eDNA at The Sound of Elsinore, Denmark — the eDNA bar comes from 0.5 litre of seawater.
Release, degradation, transportation, and sedimentation — each with its own abiotic and biotic drivers (Takahashi et al. 2023)
Environmental DNA detection rates by qPCR in natural freshwater ponds — % positive localities out of the total surveyed for each species.
In lakes and ponds the signal stays where the organism is. In streams it arrives from upstream, so a detection is a statement about a catchment, not a site.
What criteria constitute a species detection?
The lack of consensus results from context dependency — total species diversity, sequencing depth, marker specificity — and from the trade-off between stringency and uncertainty when interpreting metabarcoding results.
Which markers? What frequency across samples?
Klymus et al. 2019
A decision strategy for an eDNA monitoring approach to non-indigenous species (NIS): targeted or whole-community, semi-quantitative or qualitative, lab-based or on-site.
Equus quagga quagga — väljasurnud sebrataoline hobuslane
Sedimentary ancient DNA sequences reveal marine ecosystem shifts and indicator taxa for glacial–interglacial sea-ice conditions
Cytosine deamination at the fragment ends produces the C→T excess in the first few positions. Modern contaminant reads do not show it — which is why the damage pattern is used as evidence of authenticity, not just as a nuisance.
The 16S rRNA gene is about 1600 bp long and includes nine hypervariable regions (V1–V9) of varying conservation.
V3 and V4 are the most commonly used — a suitable length for second-generation sequencing, combined with good variability.
Earth Microbiome Project Ontology (EMPO) categories: free-living vs host-associated, saline vs non-saline, and the substrate — a controlled vocabulary that makes thousands of independent studies comparable.
SILVA taxonomy, v138.2 released July 2024.
The Greengenes2 phylogeny — Bray–Curtis on collapsed genus data, weighted UniFrac at ASV and genome identifier levels.
EUKARYOME — a community-curated database for 18S (SSU), ITS, and 28S (LSU) markers for all eukaryotes.
High copy number (so it amplifies from poor material), no recombination (so lineages form a network), and maternal inheritance (so the genealogy is simple). The cost is that it tracks one locus and only the female line.
Their mitochondrial substitution rates are low, so interspecific COI variation is often too small to separate species. Plants use rbcL, matK, and trnH-psbA; fungi use ITS.
The gap between intraspecific and interspecific genetic distances — 1.1% vs 18.1% in the mayfly example. Where recent divergence, hybridisation, or introgression closes it, sequences cannot be assigned to species with any threshold.
Below the LOD, detection is stochastic: the target may not enter the reaction at all. Replication converts a single uncertain result into a detection frequency, which is the quantity you can actually interpret.
By its damage: short fragments and an excess of C→T substitutions at the fragment ends from cytosine deamination. Contaminating modern DNA is long and undamaged.
Tähtis
peeter.laas@ut.ee · peeter.laas@taltech.ee
Next lecture: sampling and nucleic acid extraction — how the material that all of this depends on is actually obtained.
Fall 2026