Today we cover

  • what “next generation” actually means — and the three generations;
  • second generation: 454, SOLiD, Illumina, MGI — and the workflow they share;
  • third generation: HeliScope, PacBio, nanopore — single molecules, long reads;
  • methodological advances: hybrid assembly, targeted and deep sequencing;
  • molecular ecology applications: markers, SNPs, transcriptomics, epigenomics.

Next-generation sequencing (NGS)

  • First generation — Sanger’s dideoxynucleotide chain-termination method (1977); low throughput.
  • Second generation — high throughput, requires amplification, massively parallel sequencing (MPS).
  • Third generation — high throughput, no amplification required, single-molecule platforms.

Some terms

  • Read length; sequence reads and Gbp obtained per run;
  • amplicon sequencing vs shotgun sequencing;
  • base call, depth of coverage, average read depth;
  • Phred quality score (Q) — assigned to every base call;
  • FASTA vs FASTQ — FASTQ encodes Q scores alongside the read.

Phred scores are logarithmic

tibble::tibble(Q = c(10, 20, 30, 40)) |>
  mutate(p_error  = 10^(-Q/10),
         accuracy = scales::percent(1 - p_error,
                                    accuracy = 0.0001)) |>
  knitr::kable()
Q p_error accuracy
10 1e-01 90.0000%
20 1e-02 99.0000%
30 1e-03 99.9000%
40 1e-04 99.9900%

Q30 — the usual quality threshold — means one wrong base in a thousand. At 300 bp per read that is still, on average, 0.3 errors per read.

Multiplexing

Multiplexing lets a large number of libraries be pooled and sequenced together in a single run. Each library carries an index (barcode); after sequencing, reads are demultiplexed back to their sample and aligned.

Second generation

The workflow they all share

Fragment → adapters → clonal amplification → immobilise on a surface → cycle chemistry with imaging → base calls → assembly or mapping.

Pyrosequencing — Roche 454

  • The first commercial next-generation platform: Roche 454 GenomeSequencer (2005); the technology existed from the mid-1990s.
  • Sequencing by synthesis:
    1. ligate 454-specific adapters to fragments;
    2. bind one fragment per bead;
    3. emulsion PCR (emPCR);
    4. load beads into the picotiter plate.

Pyrosequencing — the chemistry

Cycles of dTTP, dCTP, dGTP — but dATPαS instead of dATP, because luciferase would use ATP itself.

PPi released on incorporation → APS → ATP → luciferase → light, read by a CCD camera. Apyrase degrades unincorporated nucleotides between cycles.

Pyrosequencing — why it died

  • Disadvantages: high sequence error rate — especially in homopolymers, where light intensity has to be read as a length — and comparatively few reads per run.
  • Early landmark use: one million base pairs of Neanderthal DNA (Green et al. 2006).
  • Roche announced discontinuation in 2013, and stopped supporting the platform entirely during 2016.

Märkus

454 gave 16S researchers their first community-scale datasets. A great deal of early microbial-ecology literature carries its homopolymer errors as OTU inflation.

SOLiD

  • Introduced in autumn 2007.
  • Parallel sequencing by stepwise ligation — sequencing by ligation, not synthesis.
  • Extremely high throughput of short reads, cheaply.
  • Like 454: emPCR — but the beads are then covalently attached to a glass slide.

SOLiD — two-base encoding

Fluorescent-labelled DNA octamers, a di-base colour code, and five universal sequencing primers offset by one position.

Every base is interrogated twice, in two different ligation rounds — which is what gave SOLiD its inherent error correction.

Illumina (Solexa)

  • 1998 — Solexa founded by Cambridge-based researchers;
  • 2004 — Solexa acquires molecular clustering technology from Manteia;
  • 2006 — Genome Analyzer, the first Solexa sequencer;
  • 2007 — Illumina acquires Solexa.

Cheaper to produce and more competitively priced than 454.

Cost of a human genome: $10M in 2007 → $100k in 2009 → $1000 in 2014.

Illumina — library and cluster generation

Sequencing by synthesis, on a flow cell:

  • a system of adapters and complementary adapters (tagmentation);
  • cluster generation on the chip via bridge amplification;
  • annealing of the sequencing primer.

Each cluster is ~1000 identical copies — enough photons to see one base.

Illumina — the cycle

Reversible terminators carry a dye and a 3′ blocking group. Extend one base, image, cleave the dye and the block, repeat.

4-channel systems use four dyes; 2-channel systems encode the four bases as red, green, both, or neither.

Illumina — from image to file

Several million clusters are amplified at distinguishable locations, imaged by camera, and turned into per-cluster base calls in a text file.

Single-end and paired-end

  • Single-end (SE) — one read from one end of the insert.
  • Paired-end (PE) — a second read from the other end. Reads 1 and 2 must overlap if you want the full insert sequence.

The insert size and the inner distance are the numbers your assembler and your amplicon merger both need.

MGI — a second-generation alternative

Library preparation ends in circularisation: the insert plus barcode is closed into a single-stranded circle with a splint oligo.

MGI — DNA nanoballs

  • linear amplification
  • always from the original template
  • low amplification bias
  • no error accumulation

Rolling circle amplification copies the circle hundreds of times into one long concatemer that folds into a DNA nanoball — many copies, one molecule of origin.

MGI — flow cell and chemistry

Nanoballs are loaded onto a patterned array flow cell — one ball per spot, by electrostatic interaction — and read by cPAS (combinatorial probe anchor synthesis).

Third generation

HeliScope

The Helicos single-molecule device:

  • no clonal amplification;
  • a highly sensitive fluorescence detection system;
  • sequencing by synthesis, with fragments hybridised to primers anchored at random positions on a glass cover slip.

PacBio

2010 — Pacific Biosciences real-time sequencing. A single polymerase sits at the bottom of a zero-mode waveguide; phospholinked nucleotides fluoresce as they are incorporated, and the pulse pattern is the sequence.

Because the same circular template is read repeatedly, random error averages out — the basis of HiFi reads.

ZS Genetics

The ZSG process lets electron microscopes “see” DNA, labelled with unique contrast-atom labels.

  • automated imaging;
  • 5,000–7,000 bp per molecule;
  • built-in error checking by comparing information from the two strands.

Nanopore technology

  • Oxford Nanopore Technologies;
  • MinION: about 500 tiny pores on a flow cell;
  • small and cheap;
  • high error rate;
  • long reads.

Biological nanopores for DNA sequencing were first proposed in the 1990s and made commercially available in May 2014.

MinION

The first commercial nanopore sequencing device:

  • high-throughput sequencing apparatus;
  • produces real-time data;
  • inexpensive;
  • pocket-sized and portable.

Nõuanne

Portability changes study design, not just logistics: sequencing at the sampling site removes the cold chain and the shipping permit from the critical path.

How nanopore sequencing works

  1. One protein unzips the double helix into two strands.
  2. A second protein forms the pore in the membrane and holds an adapter molecule.
  3. Negatively charged DNA travels through the channel towards the positive charge, changing the membrane’s electrical conductance.
  4. Current alternations, in the range of picoamperes, are characteristic of the bases in the pore.

Reading the current

The signal is not one base at a time — several bases sit in the constriction together, so basecalling is a model over a k-mer of current levels.

Nanopore data processing

  1. Segmentation of the raw current squiggle;
  2. base calling — increasingly a neural network;
  3. alignment to a genome.

Because basecalling is a model, old data can be recalled with a better model years later.

Devices and flow cells

Flongle · MinION · SmidgION · GridION · PromethION

Pore chemistry matters as much as the device: R9.4.1 reads through a single constriction, R10 through two — better homopolymer accuracy.

Flow cell basics

Three compartments — common reservoir, bulk buffer, buffer in the wells — shipped with storage buffer in all three, so the running buffer can be changed without changing the electrochemistry.

Comparison

Technology Reads per run Read length
Sanger (96-well plate) 96 1,000
Roche 454 (FLX) 700k 700
SOLiD (5500 W) 266M 100
Illumina (HiSeq) 312M 300
PacBio (Sequel) 370k 20,000
Nanopore (MinION) 2M 1,000–100,000

Nobody is best at both axes — which is the whole argument for hybrid approaches.

Methodological advances

Platforms side by side

Human Genome Project · second generation · third generation — the same problem, three amounts of cloning.

Combining short and long reads

Combining the strengths of different technologies:

  • short, but low error rate;
  • long, but high error rate.

Used for de novo genome assembly and for (meta)transcriptomics, where long reads resolve isoforms that short reads only imply.

A real hybrid workflow

15 Escherichia coli and 10 Staphylococcus aureus isolates from livestock and food; GeneJET genomic DNA purification.

Short reads — NextSeq (Illumina), paired-end 2 × 150 bp, 1.9–9.1 M reads per genome, Q > 20, fastp for QC and adapter removal, SPAdes de novo assembly.

Long reads — up to 269 kbp, combined with the short-read assembly.

Targeted sequencing

  • Targeted sequencing (TS) — sequencing only a subset of genes or genomic regions.
  • Target enrichment — capture of regions of interest, e.g. hybridisation to biotinylated probes isolated by magnetic pull-down.
  • Fewer targets means much higher coverage, and so more information per sample for population analyses.
  • Sequence capture: NimbleGen (Roche), SureSelect (Agilent); RainStorm (up to 4000 primer pairs); amplicon sequencing.

Exome sequencing

  • Exome sequencing, using exon capture, is one of the most widely used targeted methods.
  • The exome is the part of the genome formed by exons — the protein-encoding part of genes.
  • It usually represents less than 2% of most eukaryotic genomes.

Adaptive sequencing (ONT)

The pore reads the first part of a molecule, the software decides whether it is in the region of interest, and if not the voltage is reversed to eject the strand and free the pore. Enrichment without any wet-lab capture step.

Deep sequencing

  • Ultra-deep sequencing — coverage of 50×, 100×, or even 500–1000×.
  • Also called high-sensitivity sequencing.
  • Used when high-quality sequence is required, or when the target DNA or RNA occurs at very low frequency relative to everything else in the sample.
  • The purpose is to identify rare genetic variation — somatic variants, minority pathogen strains, low-frequency alleles in a pool.

Molecular ecology applications

Time of the ’omics

DNA, RNA, proteins, metabolites — potential, expression, and activity, each with its own sequencing-based readout.

Time of ‘big data’

The bottleneck moved from the bench to the pipeline: QC, assembly, annotation, taxonomic and functional profiling, and validation — each a set of choices that change the answer.

Marker discovery and genotyping

  • SNPs;
  • Restriction-site associated DNA (RAD) sequencing;
  • microsatellite discovery and genotyping.

RADseq is Lecture 2’s RFLP logic with a sequencer at the end: digest, size-select, sequence around the cut sites, call SNPs at thousands of loci.

Single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)

A SNP is a substitution of a single nucleotide at a specific position in the genome that is present in a sufficiently large fraction of the population — 1% or more. Rarer than that, and we call it a mutation.

SNPs fall in noncoding or coding regions; coding SNPs are synonymous or non-synonymous, and non-synonymous ones missense or nonsense.

Transcriptomics

  • The transcriptome is the population of RNA molecules; transcriptomics is its functional characterisation.
  • 2007–2017: 575 ecological studies used microarrays or RNA-seq.
  • Reverse transcriptase: RNA → cDNA.
  • SAGE — serial analysis of gene expression — analyses the frequency of genes in a cDNA library.
  • Gene expression profiling characterises which genes are expressed in a tissue and at what level.
  • Candidate gene finding — identifying the genes or regulatory sequences underlying a trait or behaviour.

Single-cell resolution

Barcoded gel beads in droplets give every cell its own barcode, so one library holds the transcriptional profile of thousands of individual cells rather than their average.

Epigenomics

  • Epigenetics is the study of changes in gene expression caused by modifications to the bases in a DNA sequence, rather than by differences in the sequence itself.
  • The common modification is addition of a methyl group to cytosine or adenine.
  • Methylation patterns differ between species and alter gene expression.
  • Other modifications include post-translational modification of histones, which remodels chromatin and alters transcription.
  • Transgenerational effects — conditions experienced by the parental generation influence the offspring generation.

Epigenomics — the methods

  • MSAP — methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism: two or more endonuclease isoschizomers that recognise the same site but differ in sensitivity to methylation.
  • Methylation sequencing brings NGS throughput and genome-wide analysis while resolving methylation at the single-nucleotide level.
  • WGBS — whole-genome bisulphite sequencing: sodium bisulphite converts non-methylated cytosines to uracil (read as thymine), while methylated cytosines are protected.
  • ChIP-seq — chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing: studies post-translational modification of histone proteins, particularly methylation and acetylation of N-terminal tail residues.

Platform characteristics — short read

Platform characteristics — long read

Check yourself

What separates second- from third-generation sequencing?

Amplification. Second-generation platforms need clonal copies of each fragment to produce enough signal; third-generation platforms read a single molecule, which removes amplification bias and allows very long reads.

Why did 454 struggle with homopolymers?

The light signal is proportional to the number of identical bases incorporated in one flow, so a run of, say, seven A’s has to be distinguished from six or eight by intensity alone.

Q30 means what, exactly?

A 1 in 1000 probability that the base call is wrong — 99.9% accuracy. Q = −10·log₁₀(P_error).

Why combine short and long reads for a genome assembly?

Long reads span repeats and structural variants so contigs join up; short reads have far lower per-base error, so they polish the consensus. Neither alone gives a contiguous and accurate assembly.

Why does bisulphite treatment let you read methylation?

Unmethylated cytosines are deaminated to uracil and then read as thymine, while methylated cytosines are protected and still read as C. Every C remaining in the read was methylated.

Thank you

Tähtis

Peeter Laas · peeter.laas@taltech.ee · peeter.laas@ut.ee

Next: from reads to inference — quality control, assembly, and the analyses these platforms actually feed.